Do you see the internet as a way to earn extra cash? Do you view it as an alternative to a traditional job?
Send any friend a story
As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. Anyone can read what you share.
Find all our Student Opinion questions here.
The internet seems to offer plenty of opportunities for teenagers to earn money: selling vintage clothes via Instagram; listing unwanted Magic and Pokémon cards on eBay; posting videos on YouTube and hoping they go viral.
Have you ever tried to make money online? Were you successful? What happened?
And if you’ve never made a dollar on the web, have you at least thought about it? What would you want to sell or do to try to earn cash on the internet?
Do you think making money online is easier or harder for most teenagers than just getting a traditional job, like working in a store, a movie theater or a restaurant? Why?
In “Here’s What’s Happening in the American Teenage Bedroom,” Taylor Lorenz writes about Rowan Winch, a 15-year-old who has had an unusual degree of success making money online:
For years, Rowan Winch was nothing if not online. Each day his alarm went off at 6 a.m. and he would roll over in his twin bed, grab his iPhone and start looking for memes — viral images and videos — to share on Instagram. He’d repost a handful to his suite of popular accounts before getting into the shower. Afterward, he would keep searching, and posting, until it was time to board the bus for school.
On the way to his high school in suburban Pennsylvania, Rowan would curl up in a seat, mining the internet for content. The point was not always quality but quantity. Between classes, at lunch, during study hall, he would keep his social media empire running with new images and videos. (His school has a relatively relaxed cellphone policy.) Rowan’s target, at the time, was 100 posts a day. (By comparison, The New York Times publishes around 250 pieces of original journalism each day, though some of those posts take longer to make.)
When he got home, Rowan would turn on his laptop and sit in front of the glowing screen for hours, or flop onto his bed, his phone hovering above his face. His Instagram feed flashed before him like a slot machine. His most popular account, @Zuccccccccccc, taking its name from Facebook’s chief executive, had 1.2 million followers. If his posts were good, his account would keeping growing. If he took some time off, growth would stall. Rowan, like most teenagers on the internet, wasn’t after fame or money, though he made a decent amount — at one point $10,000 a month and more, he said. What Rowan wanted was clout.
On the internet, clout is a social currency that can be used to obtain just about anything. Rack up enough while you’re young, and doors everywhere begin to open. College recruiters notice you. Job opportunities and internships come your way. Your social status among peers rises, money flows in. Even fame becomes a possibility, if that’s what you’re after.
“I want to have enough clout to be recognized for who I am, but I don’t ever want to see myself like a famous person,” Rowan said one day in his bedroom. “I just want to be able to have connections everywhere and be financially secure and monetize what I like doing.”
Rowan’s economy was a primarily teenage one. Mostly he sold ads on his Instagram to other teenagers looking to promote their own pages, apps or online storefronts. He negotiated deals through direct messages on Instagram and posted about 10 ads per day — some in the form of comments, links and images — on his various accounts. The profits supported his lifestyle; he bought Saint Laurent sneakers, an iPhone XR, a Gucci wallet. He planned to purchase a Tesla next year, when he’s eligible to get his driver’s license.
Rowan’s meme account was not his first business. Like many teenagers, Rowan had begun leveraging the internet early for financial and social gain. In middle school he’d order stickers in bulk on Amazon, then sell them at a markup to his classmates by promoting them on Snapchat.
By the time he reached high school, Rowan had entered the apparel resale market. He would purchase designer clothes and accessories from brands like Supreme on websites like Letgo, OfferUp and Craigslist, then resell them on Grailed, an app for consigning luxury items.
Rowan also experimented with dropshipping. This entails setting up an online storefront that ships products from third-party retailers to customers, profiting on the difference. Before he monetized his meme account, Rowan also sold shout-out videos on Fiverr. His followers could pay a small fee to receive a video of Rowan delivering a personalized message.
All of these are popular ways for teenagers to make money on the internet. Rowan, however, was unusually successful.
Students, read the entire article, then tell us:
The article’s tagline is “Rowan Winch is 15. He’s a businessman.” Do you think it’s accurate to call him a “businessman”? Do you think adults would see him as a businessman? Why or why not?
Since Rowan’s meme account on Instagram was deleted, he says he feels as if he has lost his purpose. What, in your opinion, do you think could help him? What do you think about his parents’ suggestion that he get more involved with life offline, such as by getting a part-time job or by pursuing an extracurricular activity? Why do you think Rowan’s parents are opposed to his selling things online?
How often do you think people your age get into selling things online for the money they can earn? How much of it is about building online relationships with people who follow them on social media? Where do you personally fall in this mix?
How do you define “clout”? Is it similar to or different from how it’s described in the article? Why might someone who is interested in building clout gravitate to a path like the one Rowan has taken? If you sold things online, would you leverage your social media accounts? If you are involved with online sales, how, if at all, do you use your social media platforms to promote what you sell?
Students 13 and older are invited to comment. All comments are moderated by the Learning Network staff, but please keep in mind that once your comment is accepted, it will be made public.